Loving confusion — is it okay to love same sex friends... and say so?

Originally Published: June 29, 2001 - Last Updated / Reviewed On: July 11, 2008
Share this

Alice,

What is the difference between "I like you" and "I love you"?

I mean, when I say, "I like you," to my male friends, and when I said, "I love you," to my girlfriend and my family. In my opinion, I'm not supposed to say, "I love you," to my best male friend because of homosexuality. Is it true?

Mr. Doubtful

Dear Mr. Doubtful,

If you posed your first question about 'like' and 'love' to a hundred different people, you'd probably get about a hundred different responses. Why? Because there is no one answer, no right or wrong interpretation of what it means to express like and love. Sure, most people may say that love is a stronger feeling and emotion than like, but the clarity may end there. If you think about it, aren't we lucky that we have levels to choose from when it comes to expressing the way we feel about others?

So, why would you like someone, and want to say so?

  • Because s/he is fun to be around
  • Because s/he is great to talk with about what's on your mind; s/he listens and gives good advice
  • Because s/he is warm, friendly, and nice to other people
  • Because the two of you have a lot in common
  • Because s/he respects your privacy
  • Because s/he makes you feel good about yourself
  • Because s/he has taken the time to get to know you and involve you in his or her life
  • And an infinite number of other reasons

Now, why would you love someone, and want to say it?

  • Because s/he is fun to be around
  • Because s/he is great to talk with about what's on your mind; s/he listens and gives good advice
  • Because s/he is warm, friendly, and nice to other people
  • Because the two of you have a lot in common
  • Because s/he respects your privacy
  • Because s/he makes you feel good about yourself
  • Because s/he has taken the time to get to know you and involve you in his or her life
  • And an infinite number of other reasons

Moving on to your question about homosexuality, notice that these lists don't include anything about having a crush on, wanting to have sex with, or wanting to spend the rest of your life with the object of your like, or love. That's because 'like' and 'love' don't require these feelings. You mentioned that it's okay to feel and voice love for your family, say a same sex sibling, no doubt for some of the reasons offered above, and not just because you're supposed to love your brother. Is it possible your friends can fall into this same category — especially the ones who are there for you just like family?

A guy telling a guy friend "I love you" does not mean that he's gay any more than not telling someone of the same sex that you love him means you're heterosexual. Perhaps the most important questions to ask are, what are your true feelings? And there is the question that may be at the root of your letter: how will your friend respond? Will he smile, laugh, say the same back, hug you, get it, freak out, call you a name, stop being your friend, or learn something? You can't control his response, but you may learn a lot about him from his reaction. If you want to tell your friend you love him and think that expressing your feelings might be uncomfortable for either of you, consider talking in distraction-free zones, in private, and when you're both feeling relaxed.

Think of all the time we'd save, and anxiety we'd prevent, if we didn't have to worry about the prejudice factor and how it might taint these and other incredible compliments and expressions of caring.

Like you a lot,

Alice

July 1, 2008

21431

To the reader:

As the previous respondent mentioned, there is brotherly love. I don't remember the greek term, but that's seems like what you have for your best same-sex friend. One way...

To the reader:

As the previous respondent mentioned, there is brotherly love. I don't remember the greek term, but that's seems like what you have for your best same-sex friend. One way that might reduce his potential discomfort, and yours as well, is simply mentioning that it is brotherly love. For example "You're like my brother.", "I love you like a brother." It might also help if you're not making a big declaration of it, but using it in general, like "My brother finally..." (whatever is appropriate). This is probably relevant to telling someone that you love her like a sister, although the case is different. Hope this helps.

May 9, 2004

20714
Dear Alice, I recently read a few Q...
Dear Alice, I recently read a few Q&As about whether it's okay to love same sex friends and say so... Well, I'd like to say that it's not only okay, but it's actually a really great thing to do and a good way to bond and make a friendship last. Just last week I was round at my best friend's house, and we were having one of the many deep talks that we tend to have. I was quite inebriated at the time, and I was telling him what a great friend he was, and he told me that I was his best friend and that he loved me. I returned this compliment by concurring and giving him a hug — and since then, he and I hug every time we meet or say goodbye. It's a really fantastic thing to have in a friendship, and if you feel strongly for your friends, I'd recommend you let them know. -Sir Hugsalot

May 9, 2004

20715
Dear Alice!, The word "love" is so loaded in our culture that, of course, people might have some issues expressing such a sentiment to platonic friends. In popular culture, love=sex or, as another...
Dear Alice!, The word "love" is so loaded in our culture that, of course, people might have some issues expressing such a sentiment to platonic friends. In popular culture, love=sex or, as another widely spread stereotype, love=marriage. Do movies or TV shows or pop songs ever express that love=friendship? Not that I've ever seen. With some of my closest friends, I have a good enough relationship that I can honestly say that I love them, or anything else for that matter, and they will understand and not judge. It all depends on your relationship and the honesty that goes along with it.

March 8, 2002

20408
Dear Alice, I have seen a couple of questions from readers who wanted help with verbally or otherwise expressing their "love" for friends of the same sex. I would like to address the confusion of...
Dear Alice, I have seen a couple of questions from readers who wanted help with verbally or otherwise expressing their "love" for friends of the same sex. I would like to address the confusion of what's "appropriate." Personally, I have little trouble telling my closest male friends that I love them, but I haven't told my girlfriend that I love her yet — they are very different kinds of love. The Greeks always had a number of words for love — "phileo" for brotherly love, "eros" for erotic love, and "agape" for self-sacrificing love. Up until the 20th century, at least in Europe, it was not inappropriate or unusual for men to express affection for their male friends in letters, even going so far as to say things like, "I greet you with kisses." (There was nothing homosexual assumed at the time.) Earlier in the 20th century, C.S. Lewis wrote of four loves, and one of those loves was Friendship (with a capital F). I would agree that friendship, phileo, is a kind of love, and both can and should be expressed in words — but only with those who are *very* close. Thanks for letting me express myself, Alice! -One of the Four